Mr. Steal Deal Never a fake discount

Guides

How to Spot a Fake Black Friday Discount (and What the FTC Actually Says)

November 22, 2026

Black Friday is the one week of the year when almost every price tag has a second, bigger number printed next to it. I read a lot of those tags for a living, and the honest summary is this: some of them are real, some are technically defensible but not very meaningful, and some are built to make you feel a gap that isn’t there. The trouble is that all three look the same on the product page.

This is the guide I’d want if I were shopping this week without anyone checking for me. It leans on the Federal Trade Commission’s own pricing guides rather than on my opinion, because the FTC has been explicit about what a fair price comparison looks like. Where something is my judgment instead of a published rule, I’ll say so.

One note on scope. I’m not a lawyer, and nothing here is legal advice. The FTC’s pricing guides are guidance about what the agency considers deceptive, not a checklist that proves any specific ad is illegal. What they are good for is giving you a fair standard to hold a price tag to.

The standard: what makes a “was” price honest

The relevant text is the FTC’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, which sit in 16 CFR Part 233. The section on former-price comparisons, 233.1, covers the most common sale format there is: “was $X, now $Y.”

Its test is simple to state. A former price is a fair comparison only if it was a genuine price, which the guide describes as “the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis.” A “bargain” measured against an inflated price the seller never really charged is a false bargain.

Two details in that section matter more than people expect:

  • The price doesn’t have to have produced lots of sales. The guide says a former price “is not necessarily fictitious merely because no sales at the advertised price were made.” What it asks is that the seller offered the item at that price openly and in good faith, for a genuine period.
  • The guide gives a plain example of the bad version. A pen retailer lists pens at an inflated $10 for a short stretch, then advertises a “bargain” at his usual $7.50. The guide calls that “obviously a false claim.” Swap pens for headphones and you have a lot of November.

That is the test I apply throughout the rest of this post: was the “before” price a real price, offered openly, for a real stretch of time? Everything below is a way that answer can come back no.

Pattern 1: the pre-sale markup

This is the pattern the 233.1 example describes. A price rises shortly before a sale, sometimes for only a few days, and the “discount” is then measured from the freshly raised number. On the page you see a big markdown. In the history you’d see a price that was flat for weeks, a quick step up, and a step back down to roughly where it started.

You can’t see this from the product page. The page only shows you today’s price and the number it wants you to compare it to. What you can do:

  • Look at the price a few weeks ago, not a few days ago. If you remember a price from October, or you added the item to a wishlist or cart then, that is your own record. It beats any label.
  • Check whether the item has been “on sale” repeatedly. A price that is always reduced is just the price. The FTC guide’s whole logic is that the reference has to be a price that was really charged, not one that exists mainly to be crossed out.
  • Use real price history where you can find it. That is the check I run on every deal I post, and it’s the reason most candidates never make it onto this site. I explain how I use it in how I verify deals.

A fair caution in the other direction: not every price rise before a sale is a trick. Prices move for supply reasons, and retailers do hold normal prices and then run real promotions. The test is whether the “before” price was an ordinary, sustained one. A one-week spike isn’t.

Pattern 2: “compare at,” “list price,” and “MSRP”

These labels are a different problem. The “was” number may not be a price the retailer ever charged at all. It may be a manufacturer’s suggested price, or a figure labelled “compare at” that refers to some other store’s price, or nothing in particular.

The FTC has guidance for both versions.

Manufacturer list prices. Section 233.3 covers prices “established or suggested by manufacturers.” It notes that many shoppers believe a list price is the price at which an item is generally sold, and that discounting has made list prices a less dependable indicator of what things actually cost. Its test is that a list price isn’t fictitious if “substantial (that is, not isolated or insignificant) sales” are made at that price in the advertiser’s trade area. A list price well above what anyone really pays risks misleading you.

“Compare at” and other-store comparisons. Section 233.2 covers advertisers who claim their price is below what others charge. The higher comparison price has to be factual, and the advertiser should be reasonably sure it doesn’t significantly exceed the price at which substantial sales happen in the area. The guide’s example of a misleading comparison is a “Retail Value” based on a price that only a few small outlets charge, while most local stores charge much less. Comparisons to similar merchandise are allowed if the comparison is clear and representative outlets really do sell the comparable item at the stated price.

In plain terms, here is how I handle these labels:

  • A struck-through list price tells you what someone suggested, not what anyone paid. I never use one as the reference for a deal, and I’d suggest you don’t either.
  • “Compare at” is a claim about another store. If it names no store, no product and no date, it is not information. You can check it by opening that other store’s listing yourself, and the results are often unflattering to the claim.
  • A list price that has never moved while the item has been available for less in every store for a year has a name: decoration.

Pattern 3: countdown pressure

Countdown clocks, “only 3 left,” and “12 people are looking at this” all try to speed you up. Speed is the enemy of checking a price, which is why they exist.

Some of these are genuine: a promotion really does end at midnight, or a warehouse really does have few units. The question is whether the claim is true. The FTC’s staff report Bringing Dark Patterns to Light, from September 2022, lists “baseless countdown timer” as a tactic, describing it as showing a fake countdown clock that goes away or resets when it times out. In its discussion of the evidence, the report also cites the UK Competition and Markets Authority on how false or misleading scarcity claims, including “countdown clocks that reset” can put undue pressure on consumers to act. The report also describes claims that an item is almost sold out when supply is ample, and false claims that other shoppers are looking at the same product.

What I do about it, and what you can do:

  • Reload the page, or come back later. If a timer resets or the same “ends in” clock appears again, it was never a deadline. A genuine end time doesn’t move.
  • Ask what actually changes when the clock hits zero. If the answer is “the price goes back to a number the item has rarely sold at,” the clock is selling the reference price, not the discount.
  • Treat urgency as a reason to slow down, not speed up. A deal that is only good if you don’t look at it closely is not a good deal.

I don’t use countdown language on this site, and that includes on deals that are genuinely good. If a deal is real, it doesn’t need help.

Pattern 4: bundles that hide the real price

The fourth pattern doesn’t touch the price directly. It changes what the price buys.

Section 233.4 covers bargains that depend on buying something else, including “Free,” “Buy One, Get One Free,” “2-For-1 Sale,” and “Half Price Sale.” The guide makes a point I think is underrated: “Literally, of course, the seller is not offering anything ‘free’” because you have to buy an article to get it. That’s fine in itself. The concern is what happens around it. The guide says that where the seller “increases his regular price of the article required to be bought, or decreases the quantity and quality of that article, or otherwise attaches strings” to the offer, the consumer may be deceived. Its conclusion is that all the terms and conditions should be made clear at the outset.

On the shelf, that tends to look like:

  • A “bundle deal” where the main item costs as much as it always did and the extras are accessories you’d rarely buy on their own. The “value” of the bundle is the sum of list prices for things you don’t want.
  • A “free gift” whose cost has been quietly moved into the item’s price.
  • A model or configuration that looks identical but is a different one: a lower-spec variant made for the sale, with a different model number from the version that earned the reviews.

How to check a bundle:

  1. Price the main item alone. Find the same model, same configuration, without the extras. Is the bundle price meaningfully different from the item by itself?
  2. Value the extras at what you’d really pay. If you’d never have bought the carrying case or the cables, they’re worth nothing to you, whatever the page claims.
  3. Compare model numbers, not product names. Big sale weeks are when sale-specific variants appear. If the model number differs from the one in the reviews you read, you read about a different product.

A short checklist you can run in two minutes

You won’t run all of these on every purchase. Run them on anything you’d be annoyed to overpay for.

  1. What is the “before” price? A price this retailer charged, a list price, or “compare at”? Each is a different claim.
  2. Was it a price people really paid? If you can see price history, look at the weeks before the sale, not the days. If you can’t, check whether the item has been “on sale” all year.
  3. Is there a clock? Does it reset, or does it name an end time you can plan around?
  4. What exactly is in the box? Same model number, same configuration, and an honest valuation of any extras.
  5. Would you buy it at this price if there were no strikethrough? This is the question the whole day is designed to stop you asking. It’s the best one.

What a real Black Friday deal looks like

A real one is boring to describe. The item sold at a particular price for a real stretch of time, and now it sells for less. There’s no countdown doing the persuading and no list price doing the arithmetic. The gap is the gap between two prices people paid.

That’s the standard I hold my own posts to, and it’s why a lot of what I see this week never gets posted. If you want to see what the ones that pass look like, I’m collecting them on the Black Friday page, and the same checks apply to everything in monitors, televisions and laptops, where the “was” prices tend to be most elaborate. I’d rather you read this post and buy nothing than buy something because a clock told you to.


Sources, all read for this post: FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, 16 CFR Part 233 (the sections cited are 233.1, 233.2, 233.3 and 233.4, read as published by Cornell’s Legal Information Institute); FTC staff report Bringing Dark Patterns to Light, September 2022.