Mr. Steal Deal Never a fake discount

Black Friday: real deal or fake discount?

Black Friday is the loudest week for discounts that were never discounts. This page is permanent. I keep it up every year, because the tricks don’t change. Here is how I tell the difference, and what I check before I post anything.

How to spot a fake Black Friday discount

  • The “was” price is a list price. A struck-through number next to a deal only tells you what someone wants it to look like. It isn’t what the item sold for.
  • The price crept up first. Some prices rise for a few weeks before a big sale so the drop looks larger. Without the history, you can’t see it.
  • The “deal” is the usual price. If an item bounces between the same high and low all year, the low isn’t news, even with a banner on it.
  • A countdown or “only a few left” is pressure, not proof. A real discount holds up without a clock. I don’t use one.
  • It’s a different version. Bundles and slightly different models can make a price look better than it is. The comparison has to be the exact same item.

What I check before I post

  1. At least 90 days of real price history for that exact item.
  2. That the comparison is a price it actually sold for recently, never a list price.
  3. That the drop isn’t just part of a pattern the price repeats every few weeks.
  4. That the history is solid enough to judge. If it isn’t, I skip the deal rather than guess.

If a deal fails any of these, it doesn’t go up, however good it looks. The full method is here, including where I could still be wrong.

Verified deals

Deals that were still verified when I last checked, each with its check date. Prices move, so confirm on Amazon before you buy.

Browse by category

Keep reading